Why paying for leads is a losing strategy for local contractors?

Are you a contractor relying on third party leads to generate new business? If so, you’re not alone. A lot of local contractors rely on Angie's List (or similar platforms) to keep a steady stream of potential new clients in their pipelines. That however, can end up being a costly, losing strategy for a number of reasons, and it can be a strategy that’s difficult to walk away from once you’re dependant. While these services can offer some value with increased visibility and access to potential customers, there are aspects that may not always align with the best interests of contractors like you.

What are The real Downside to relying on Payed Leads to generate new business?

Cost-Effectiveness: Paying for leads can be expensive, especially if the leads are not exclusive and are being sold to multiple contractors. This can significantly reduce the return on investment, as the cost of acquiring a customer increases.

Quality of Leads: The quality of purchased leads can be variable. Some leads may not be fully vetted or may not be as interested as initially thought. This means contractors might spend a lot of time and energy following up on leads that do not convert into actual business.

Competition: When leads are not exclusive, contractors find themselves in direct competition with others who have received the same lead. This can drive down prices and margins as contractors bid against each other for the same job.

Dependence on Third Parties: Relying on purchased leads means depending on external sources for business growth. This can be risky, as changes in lead quality, price, or availability can directly impact the contractor's business.

Lack of Relationship Building: Paying for leads does not foster initial trust and rapport with potential clients in the same way that referrals or organic leads do. Building a business on relationships and trust is crucial in the local contractor space, where reputation is a key factor in securing projects.

Short-term Strategy: Focusing on buying leads can be seen as a short-term strategy. It might not contribute to long-term business growth, such as building a strong brand, establishing a local presence, or generating repeat business and referrals from satisfied customers.

Inefficiency: Not all paid leads convert into paying customers, leading to inefficiencies in the contractor's marketing strategy. Resources could be better spent on strategies that enhance the contractor's visibility and reputation in the local community, such as search engine optimization (SEO), content marketing, or community involvement.

That being said, paying for leads can be beneficial in some scenarios, particularly if the leads are high-quality, targeted, and have a good conversion rate. It's important for contractors to carefully evaluate the cost and quality of leads from different sources and consider how they fit into a broader, diversified marketing strategy.

What are the alternatives to paying for expensive third party leads?

Alternatively, contractors looking to generate new leads without relying on third-party vendors can adopt several strategies to attract potential clients through organic and direct channels. These methods often focus on building a strong brand presence, establishing trust within the community, and leveraging digital marketing techniques. Here are some the most effective strategies:

Optimize Local SEO: Ensure your business is easily found on search engines, especially for local searches. This involves optimizing your website for relevant keywords, maintaining an up-to-date Google My Business listing, and ensuring your NAP (Name, Address, Phone number) is consistent across all online platforms.

Content Marketing: Create valuable content related to your services, such as blog posts, how-to guides, and videos. This can help establish your authority in your field, improve your search engine rankings, and attract organic traffic to your website.

Social Media Engagement: Use social media platforms to showcase your work, share insights, and engage with your community. Platforms like Instagram, Facebook, and LinkedIn can be particularly effective for visual content, customer testimonials, and sharing success stories.

Email Marketing: Collect email addresses from your website visitors (with their permission) and send them regular updates, offers, and valuable content. This keeps your business top-of-mind and encourages repeat business and referrals.

Networking and Partnerships: Build relationships with other local businesses, suppliers, and contractors. This can lead to referral opportunities and partnerships that bring in new leads. Participating in local trade shows, business groups, and community events can also increase your visibility.

Referral Programs: Encourage your satisfied customers to refer new clients by offering them incentives, such as discounts on future services or small thank-you gifts. Word-of-mouth is a powerful tool in the contracting business.

Customer Reviews and Testimonials: Encourage happy customers to leave positive reviews online, such as on Google, Yelp, or industry-specific review sites. Showcase these testimonials on your website and social media channels to build trust with potential clients.

Direct Mail: While digital marketing is crucial, direct mail campaigns can still be effective, especially for targeting specific neighborhoods or demographics. Sending postcards, flyers, or letters with special offers or showcasing your portfolio can capture the attention of potential clients.

Local Advertising: Consider local advertising options that fit your budget and target audience, such as local newspapers, radio stations, community bulletin boards, or online local forums and directories.

Offer Workshops or Seminars: Hosting free or low-cost workshops on topics related to your services can help establish your expertise and attract potential clients interested in your area of work.

Implementing a combination of these strategies can help contractors generate new leads more effectively and sustainably than relying solely on purchasing leads from third-party vendors. The key is to build a strong, trustworthy brand and engage directly with your target audience.

Don’t forget to sign up for the Highly Effective, Low Cost Lead Strategies for Local Contractors Newsletter for more up to date, actionable strategies that you can implement yourself!